I vote for the Holley (particularly if it is a gold box version), cause if you're going to use it to trigger a msd then you can convert it to a motorcraft or mopar pickup and use the vr connection (the purple and green 2 terminal plug) on the msd instead of the white wire. No sense in spending the money on a pertronix just to use it as a trigger, just adds complexity and another not so cheap failure point.
Any Holley distributor May be converted to a mag trigger. Why would anyone waste an operational gold box distributor to do this??? Key word..."operational" (meaning the hall effect trigger component is functional).
And converting any Holley distributor to a mag trigger is a totally worthless operation unless the distributor has been completely reconditioned in it's entirety first.
How the hell does adding a pertronix hall effect conversion trigger add "complexity" to any distributor or ignition system?? A p-tron simply drops in and goes with no juryrigging required whether used to trigger a cd box or in stand-alone mode. And ya think a duraspark or chrysler (or delco hei) mag trigger never fails??? You ain't been workin' on cars very long son.
Last I checked (I converted three Holley distributors to mag triggers over the weekend), a pertronix conversion uses a pickup and a magnet wheel. That is...two parts. A mag trigger conversion uses ...two parts...a reluctor and a pickup...along with a whole bunch of fabrication that many folks are not capable of in order to be successful. So what's the difference???
There is absolutely no performance or durability advantage to a mag trigger over a pertronix for use with a carbureted engine. Any cd box has two completely separate "input" provisions, one for a "points (read breaker points, pertronix, hall effect, etc.) input" and one for use only with a mag trigger. Ya never use both off the same distributor.
An ignition system "trigger" is a dam trigger...no matter if breaker points, a light beam, a hall effect sensor, a magnetic trigger, a crank sensor, or a proximity detector.